Same 2-inch wheel. 3.9 kW on R245fa, 70 kW on CO2.
Infinity Turbine's 2012 inflow radial turbine rotor was drawn for R245fa. Run the numbers with CO2 at the same 100 °C heat source and 10 °C cooling, and the same 50.8 mm wheel becomes a 50–70 kW-class machine. This analysis shows why, what it costs in pump power, and how the wheel behaves on a small CO2 lab cart.
Measured geometry · meanline method · wheel capacity · partial admission · expander comparison · rotor stress · recommendations
A well-proportioned wheel, sized for much more flow than a lab cart
This is a conventional 2-inch radial inflow turbine wheel. With CO2 at its natural operating point it would pass about 2.8 kg/s at about 68,000 rpm, roughly 16 times what the Cat 310 pump can supply.
On the lab cart it can only run in deep partial admission at reduced speed: about 2.4 kW at 4 gpm and about 150 W at 20,000 BTU/hr. Running it at its CO2 design speed on the cart would cost more power in churning the idle blade passages than it produces.
- Original R245fa duty: about 3.9 kW shaft at 0.13 kg/s and about 75,000 rpm.
- CO2 at full flow: about 48 kW at 100 bar or 70 kW at 120 bar. It needs 0.55–0.62 MW of 100 °C heat and a 2.3–2.8 kg/s pump using 15–26 kW.
- On the lab cart: the nozzle covers only 1–4 % of the rotor circumference. Best speeds are 15–32k rpm, at 23–43 % efficiency.
- Versus other cart expanders: below the bucket turbine at 4 gpm, and below the Tesla stack at 20,000 BTU/hr.
- Mechanical: at 68,000 rpm the bore stress in 304 stainless reaches yield. Use 17-4PH H1025 or Ti-6Al-4V for full-speed CO2 work. At 25–35k rpm, 304 is fine.
What the 2012 files show
Geometry was measured by slicing the 2012 STL model every 0.02 in and checked against the 2013 ITmicro Radial Impeller drawing, which has the same Ø2.000 × 0.750 in envelope in 304 stainless.
| Dimension | Imperial | Metric | Source / note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wheel / back-disc diameter | 2.000 in | 50.8 mm | STL and 2013 drawing |
| Rotor inlet (blade tip) radius r1 | 0.975 in | 24.8 mm | STL slices |
| Inlet blade height b1 | 0.12 in | 3.0 mm | STL, back face to shroud break |
| Back-disc thickness | 0.063 in | 1.6 mm | Drawing |
| Exducer hub / tip radius | 0.33 / 0.59 in | 8.4 / 15.0 mm | STL at z = 0.70 in; r3s/r1 = 0.61 |
| Exit annulus area (gross) | 0.751 in² | 4.85 cm² | About 12 % blade blockage assumed |
| Inlet passage area (gross) | 0.735 in² | 4.74 cm² | 2π r1 b1 |
| Overall axial length | 0.750 in | 19.05 mm | STL and drawing |
| Blades | 10 full + 10 splitters | Splitters end about 0.57 in from the back face | |
| Inlet blade angle | About 0° (radial element) | Planar wrap under about 10° | |
| Exducer exit blade angle | About 60–62° from axial | Blade wrap 4–5° per 0.02 in near the exit | |
| Blade thickness (exducer) | About 0.03 in | About 0.8 mm | STL sections |
| Bore / counterbore | Ø0.265 thru / Ø0.394 × 0.625 deep | Ø6.7 / Ø10.0 mm | Drawing |
| Volume / mass (304 SS) | 0.934 in³ | 121 g | STL volume |
The STEP file path ("CO2T_LCO2 turbine with pump") and its name ("R245 Inflow Radial Turbine") suggest the wheel was drawn for R245fa and considered for CO2.
One-dimensional meanline, real-fluid properties
Fluid properties come from CoolProp 8.0 (Span–Wagner for CO2, Lemmon for R245fa). The same cycle basis is used for both fluids so the comparison is like for like.
- Cycle: 100 °C source, turbine inlet 90 °C; 10 °C cooling water, so CO2 condenses at 18 °C (54.7 bar). R245fa: saturated at 85 °C (8.9 bar), 5 K superheat, condensing at 18 °C (1.14 bar).
- Design speed: classic radial-turbine optimum, blade-tip speed U1 = 0.70 × spouting velocity c0.
- Flow capacity: set by the exducer, exit axial velocity C3 = 0.25 U1. This gives specific speed Ns = 0.41 for every fluid, with peak efficiency about 78 % from a radial-turbine Ns correlation.
CO2 versus R245fa at the wheel's natural operating point
With CO2, the same 2-inch wheel produces 12–18× the shaft power it makes on R245fa. The cost is a much larger pump: back-work is 30–37 % for CO2 versus 2 % for R245fa.
| At the natural operating point | R245fa (design fluid) | CO2, 100 bar | CO2, 120 bar |
|---|---|---|---|
| Turbine inlet | 8.9 bar / 90 °C (129 psia / 194 °F) | 100 bar / 90 °C (1,450 psia) | 120 bar / 90 °C (1,740 psia) |
| Pressure ratio | 7.8 | 1.81 | 2.17 |
| Isentropic enthalpy drop | 38.6 kJ/kg | 27.2 kJ/kg | 31.5 kJ/kg |
| Spouting velocity c0 / nozzle Mach | 278 m/s / 1.9 | 233 m/s / 0.95 | 251 m/s / 1.10 |
| Design speed (U1/c0 = 0.70) | 75,008 rpm (195 m/s) | 62,940 rpm (163 m/s) | 67,766 rpm (176 m/s) |
| Exhaust density | 6.3 kg/m³ | 130 kg/m³ | 150 kg/m³ |
| Mass flow capacity | 0.13 kg/s (17 lb/min) | 2.26 kg/s (298 lb/min) | 2.82 kg/s (373 lb/min) |
| Specific speed Ns / est. efficiency | 0.41 / 78 % | 0.41 / 78 % | 0.41 / 78 % |
| Shaft power | 3.9 kW (5.3 hp) | 48.0 kW (64 hp) | 69.6 kW (93 hp) |
| Heat input required | 33 kW (111,524 BTU/hr) | 548 kW (1.87 M BTU/hr) | 623 kW (2.13 M BTU/hr) |
| Pump work (fluid) | 0.09 kW | 14.6 kW | 26.1 kW |
| Net electric (95 % generator, 85 % pump drive) | 3.6 kW | 28.4 kW | 35.4 kW |
Density does the work
CO2 leaves the turbine about 24× denser than R245fa, so far more mass flows through the same passages.
Easier nozzle
The R245fa nozzle is supersonic (Mach 1.9). The CO2 nozzle is near sonic (Mach 0.95–1.10).
Bigger pump
CO2 back-work is 30–37 % of shaft power versus 2 % for R245fa, so net electric is 28–35 kW, not 48–70 kW.
Deep partial admission at reduced speed
At cart flows the nozzle arc is less than one blade passage wide (inlet blade pitch is 7.8 mm). The idle passages churn dense CO2 at about 150 kg/m³, so the best speed drops well below the design point.
| Flow case | CO2 flow | Admitted arc | Nozzle area | Best speed | Isentropic power | Net shaft | Efficiency |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20,000 BTU/hr (24 g/s) | 0.024 kg/s (3.2 lb/min) | 0.7 % (1.0 mm) | 0.8 mm² | 15,000 rpm | 0.66 kW | 0.15 kW | 23 % |
| Cat 310 1 gpm | 0.044 kg/s (5.9 lb/min) | 1.0 % (1.5 mm) | 1.2 mm² | 19,000 rpm | 1.40 kW | 0.38 kW | 27 % |
| Cat 310 2 gpm | 0.089 kg/s (11.8 lb/min) | 1.9 % (3.0 mm) | 2.4 mm² | 25,000 rpm | 2.80 kW | 0.97 kW | 35 % |
| Cat 310 3 gpm | 0.133 kg/s (17.6 lb/min) | 2.9 % (4.5 mm) | 3.5 mm² | 29,000 rpm | 4.20 kW | 1.66 kW | 39 % |
| Cat 310 4 gpm | 0.178 kg/s (23.5 lb/min) | 3.8 % (6.0 mm) | 4.7 mm² | 32,000 rpm | 5.61 kW | 2.41 kW | 43 % |
Cat 310 cases at 120 bar; the 20,000 BTU/hr case at 100 bar.
Against the other lab-cart expanders
At 4 gpm, this wheel (about 2.41 kW) is below the bucket turbine estimate (3.65 kW at an assumed 65 %). At 20,000 BTU/hr it is below even the Tesla stack (about 0.15 kW versus a 0.29 kW model ceiling).
On the cart, this wheel is a reasonable demonstrator at 3–4 gpm but not the best performer. Its strength is at much higher flow.
Bucket turbine and Tesla figures are from the earlier lab-cart and Tesla reports in this series.
Rotor stress versus speed
| Speed | Tip speed | Nominal centre stress | At bore (×2) | 304 SS (yield about 205 MPa annealed) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 32,000 rpm (cart, 4 gpm) | 83 m/s | 22 MPa | 45 MPa | Fine |
| 50,000 rpm | 130 m/s | 55 MPa | 110 MPa | Acceptable |
| 68,000 rpm (CO2 design) | 176 m/s | 101 MPa | 203 MPa | At yield: use 17-4PH H1025 or Ti-6Al-4V |
| 75,000 rpm (R245fa design) | 195 m/s | 125 MPa | 250 MPa | Over yield |
Stresses use the rotating-disc approximation (3+ν)/8·ρU², doubled at the bore.
Size the rotor and bearings for full admission
- Material: at the 68,000 rpm CO2 design speed, 304 stainless reaches yield at the bore. Re-make the wheel in 17-4PH H1025 or Ti-6Al-4V for any run above about 50k rpm.
- FEA: blade root and splitter stresses need a proper finite-element check before any high-speed run.
- Balance to G2.5 or better.
- Thrust: with CO2 the back face sees roughly nozzle-exit pressure and the exducer sees exhaust pressure. Size the axial thrust bearing for the full-admission case even if the cart runs in partial admission.
- Pressure: CO2 turbine inlets here run at 100–120 bar (1,450–1,740 psia). Casing, seals and piping must be rated accordingly.
What to do with this wheel
- On the lab cart (Cat 310, 1–4 gpm): run one converging nozzle of about 4.7 mm² (4 gpm) to 1.2 mm² (1 gpm), set about 75° from radial, at 25–35k rpm. Shroud the non-admitted arc to cut ventilation; this could add several hundred watts. Expect about 1.5–2.5 kW at 3–4 gpm.
- Skip it for the 20,000 BTU/hr case (about 0.15 kW). A positive-displacement or hydraulic expander, such as the ROT 06 concept, or a much smaller impulse wheel suits that flow better.
- As a production machine, this wheel suits CO2 at about 2.3–2.8 kg/s: 48–70 kW shaft from 0.55–0.62 MW of 100 °C heat. That is a natural single-module size for the Cluster Mesh data-center waste-heat concept, with a pump in the 15–26 kW class.
- Baseline with R245fa: run the wheel on the IT10 at its design fluid (about 3.9 kW at 0.13 kg/s) to get a measured efficiency that calibrates the CO2 predictions.
- Above about 50k rpm on CO2: re-make the wheel in 17-4PH or titanium, check blades by FEA, balance to G2.5 or better, and design the thrust bearing for CO2 pressures.
- Scaling is the problem at cart flows. Holding the same specific speed at 0.18 kg/s would need a 12 mm wheel at about 270,000 rpm. That is why small CO2 test loops favor partial-admission impulse or positive-displacement expanders.
Report, CO2 turbines and project help
CO2 Duty Analysis Report
- 7-page engineering report
- Measured rotor geometry and drawings
- CO2 vs R245fa capacity tables
- Lab-cart partial admission, stress and recommendations
50–70 kW CO2 module
- 2.3–2.8 kg/s CO2 per module
- 0.55–0.62 MW of 100 °C heat
- Cluster Mesh concept sizing
Turbine consulting
- Radial and impulse turbine sizing
- CO2 and ORC cycle analysis
- Test loop and expander selection
Common questions
Why does the same wheel make so much more power on CO2?
CO2 at the turbine exit is about 24× denser than R245fa, so the same passages carry about 20× more mass flow (2.8 kg/s versus 0.13 kg/s). The enthalpy drop per kilogram is a little lower, but the mass flow wins: about 70 kW versus 3.9 kW shaft.
Is the 70 kW net electric?
No. 69.6 kW is shaft power at 120 bar. The CO2 pump takes about 26 kW of fluid work, so net electric is about 35 kW with a 95 % generator and 85 % pump drive. At 100 bar it is 48 kW shaft and about 28 kW net.
Why not run it at full speed on the lab cart?
The cart's Cat 310 pump supplies about 1/16 of the wheel's flow capacity, so the nozzle covers only 1–4 % of the circumference. The idle passages churn dense CO2, and that ventilation loss grows with the cube of speed: about 6 kW at 68,000 rpm, more than any cart flow can supply.
Can the 304 stainless wheel run at CO2 design speed?
Not safely. At 68,000 rpm the bore stress is about 203 MPa, at the yield of annealed 304. Use 17-4PH H1025 or Ti-6Al-4V, verify by FEA and balance to G2.5 or better. At the cart's 25–35k rpm, 304 is fine.
What expander suits a small CO2 test loop?
At cart flows, a radial wheel with the same specific speed would be 12 mm across and spin at about 270,000 rpm. Partial-admission impulse wheels or positive-displacement expanders are the practical choice there.
Small wheel. Dense fluid. Big output.
The same 2-inch rotor goes from 3.9 kW on R245fa to 70 kW on CO2, given the flow and heat to feed it.
Questions? Email greg@infinityturbine.com