The CO₂ thermodynamic cycle sets the ceiling, and each extra conversion step after the expander removes a few percent. For electricity, a CO₂ turbine directly driving a high-speed generator is the most efficient route wherever the scale supports a good turbine (roughly 100 kW and up, and especially multi-MW sCO₂ Brayton at 500–700 °C, where cycle efficiencies reach 40–50%). When the output you need is hydraulic force, especially at small scale (10–200 kW) and low speed, a CO₂ piston expander driving hydraulic fluid directly is the most efficient route. It skips the generator and pump stages and suits the high pressure ratios and low flow rates where small turbines perform poorly.
Spinning a turbine to make hydraulic pressure only makes sense when hydraulic output is the end use. CO₂-entrained ferrofluid is the least efficient by a wide margin, below 1% heat-to-work. Its magnetic forces are about 1,000× weaker than hydraulic pressure, and CO₂ attacks the fluid's chemistry.
The best combined design is a double-acting free-piston CO₂ expander. Its rod carries a permanent-magnet section inside copper coils, which form a linear alternator and motor, and ends in a hydraulic plunger. Ferrofluid serves as rod seals and gap coolant, and MR fluid as the stroke damper. It does not beat thermodynamics. Its advantage is that it eliminates the crankshaft, gearbox, rotary generator and separate pump, and delivers electricity, hydraulic power or both from one moving part.
| Path | Description | Conversion chain |
|---|---|---|
| A Turbine → generator | CO₂ expands through a radial, axial or Tesla turbine on the same shaft as a high-speed PM generator. Power electronics condition the output. | Heat → CO₂ → turbine shaft → generator → electricity |
| B Turbine → hydraulic | The turbine drives a hydraulic pump, through a gearbox if speeds don't match. Oil pressure drives cylinders or a hydraulic motor. | Heat → CO₂ → turbine → (gearbox) → pump → oil → motor or cylinder |
| C Heated CO₂ piston → hydraulic cylinder | High-pressure CO₂ from an external heater is admitted to a piston expander. The piston acts directly on a hydraulic plunger, with no crank. A batch variant heats CO₂ inside the cylinder itself. | Heat → CO₂ → piston → oil (direct) → cylinder or motor |
| D CO₂ entrained in ferrofluid | CO₂ dissolved or bubbled in a ferrofluid is heated to release and expand it, pressurizing the liquid. Optionally a magnetic field pumps it (thermomagnetic effect), or the moving fluid passes through coils. | Heat → CO₂ desorption/expansion and ferrofluid magnetization → liquid pressure → (coil EMF) |
Each figure below multiplies typical component efficiencies. It shows how much of the ideal CO₂ expansion work reaches the useful output.
| Path | Large scale (>5 MW, 550–700 °C, sCO₂ Brayton) | Small scale (50–150 kW, ~250 °C, transcritical Rankine) | Low grade (≤110 °C, transcritical Rankine) | Output type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Turbine → generator | 40–50% | 10–15% | 5–8% | Electricity |
| B Turbine → hydraulic | 32–42% (rarely used) | 8–13% | 4–6% | Hydraulic |
| C Piston → hydraulic (external heater, recuperated) | Not practical (flow too large) | 11–15% | 5–8% | Hydraulic |
| C′ Piston, batch-heated in cylinder | — | 3–6% | 1–3% | Hydraulic |
| D CO₂-entrained ferrofluid | — | <1% | <0.5% | Liquid pressure, µW–W electric |
| S Supermotive free-piston | Not practical | 11–15% (electric or hydraulic) | 5–8% | Both |
Ranges are net of CO₂ pump work and use realistic heat-exchanger approach temperatures and recuperation. Carnot limits for reference: about 65% at 650 °C, about 45% at 250 °C, about 26% at 110 °C (sink at 10–15 °C). Use these for screening only. Design numbers need a cycle model with real fluid properties (e.g., REFPROP/CoolProp).
Scale: 0–25% heat-to-output.
1Large scale, electricity: A sCO₂ turbine with a direct high-speed generator. No other path comes close at MW scale and high temperature.
1Small scale, hydraulic output: C piston expander driving oil directly. It needs an external heater, a recuperator, timed inlet valves and a crankless free piston. This is the best match for a remote wood-fired system whose job is hydraulic work.
2Small scale, electricity: A and S are close. Low-cost turbines (e.g., 1,800–3,600 rpm direct-drive) are simpler. A free-piston linear alternator wins where pressure ratios are high and flows small.
3B is worthwhile only when hydraulic output is the end goal and a turbine already exists.
4D is a research curiosity, not a power path (see Section 4).
| Issue | Detail | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Weak magnetic force | Ferrofluid saturation magnetization is about 30–90 kA/m, giving magnetic pressure of about 1–10 kPa. Hydraulic oil runs at 20–40 MPa and CO₂ at 6–14 MPa. | The magnetic contribution is about 1/1,000 to 1/10,000 of the CO₂ or hydraulic pressure, so it adds essentially nothing to power. |
| Coils around flowing ferrofluid | Flux from a ferrofluid slug is about μ₀M ≈ 0.04–0.1 T, vs 1.2–1.4 T for NdFeB. Induced power scales roughly with B². | About 150–1,000× less power per unit volume than a magnet-piston linear alternator. Entrained gas bubbles dilute it further. |
| CO₂ chemistry | Pressurized and supercritical CO₂ dissolves in or extracts hydrocarbon and ester carrier oils and is highly soluble in fluorocarbons. In water carriers it forms carbonic acid, which attacks magnetite. | Swelling, foaming on depressurization, surfactant stripping, particle clumping and loss of the colloid. |
| Thermomagnetic pumping | Works by magnetization falling as temperature approaches the particle Curie point (magnetite is about 585 °C, so only a small change across practical ΔT). | Heat-to-work efficiency well under 1%. Useful only for no-moving-part circulation at very low head. |
| Gas-in-liquid expansion | Releasing dissolved CO₂ by heating does pressurize a liquid, but it is an unrecuperated batch process. | Behaves like batch heating (C′) with even worse heat transfer and slower dynamics. |
This concept puts all three motion types on one moving rod: linear CO₂ expansion, electromagnetic conversion (coils around a magnet section, the rotary motor's principle unrolled into a line) and hydraulic force. Magnetic fluids act as enablers.
| Element | Function | Motion type | Design notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| ① Double-acting CO₂ expander | Hot, high-pressure CO₂ is admitted alternately to each side of the piston through timed valves, expands, then exhausts to the recuperator. | Linear (thermal) | Electronically timed solenoid or rotary valves set the cutoff, the expansion ratio being matched to load. Piston rings or clearance seal plus a buffer zone. Hot end isolated thermally from the magnets. |
| ② Linear alternator / motor | A NdFeB or SmCo magnet section on the rod moves inside copper coils to generate electricity. The same coils act as a linear motor to start, centre and control the stroke, replacing the crank and flywheel. | Electromagnetic | Keep magnets below their temperature limit (NdFeB about 80–150 °C; SmCo to about 300 °C). Proven in free-piston Stirling engines, where alternators reach 90%+ efficiency. An active rectifier/inverter controls stroke frequency and amplitude. |
| ③ Hydraulic plunger | The rod end pumps oil into an accumulator. Valves set the split between electrical and hydraulic output, or switch to hydraulic only. | Hydraulic (linear) | Area ratio between CO₂ piston and plunger sets pressure intensification (e.g., 100 bar CO₂ → 250–300 bar oil). The accumulator smooths pulses. Can drive the CO₂ feed pump directly. |
| Ferrofluid seals | Zero-leak, low-friction magnetic liquid seals on the rod between sections. | Magnetic fluid | Only at low-pressure boundaries (about 0.2–0.3 bar per stage). The main CO₂ pressure is held by rings or labyrinths, with ferrofluid as the final buffer. Choose a carrier fluid for CO₂ compatibility and test it. |
| Ferrofluid gap coolant | Fills the alternator air gap to carry coil heat to the housing and slightly increase flux. | Magnetic fluid | Static fluid with no CO₂ contact. Proven in loudspeakers. |
| MR fluid damper | Electronically controlled end-of-stroke cushion and emergency brake if load is lost. | Semi-magnetic fluid | Responds in 5–20 ms. Prevents piston over-travel, which is the main failure mode of free-piston machines. |
| Risk | Mitigation |
|---|---|
| Stroke control (no crank sets the stroke limits) | Closed-loop coil force control, position sensing, MR end dampers and a hydraulic end cushion. |
| Magnet temperature | Tandem layout with the hot cylinder separated from the alternator, a cooled rod section, SmCo magnets, and ferrofluid gap cooling. |
| CO₂ blow-by and sealing at 60–140 bar | Stepped seals: rings, then labyrinth, then a vented buffer, then a ferrofluid final seal. Return blow-by to the condenser side. |
| Valve losses and timing | Large-area fast valves, cam-less electronic actuation, and inlet cutoff tuned to the expansion ratio. |
| Vibration from a single piston | Opposed twin pistons on one axis (mirror-image units) to balance the forces. |
| Power density vs turbines | Accept a larger size for lower cost and robustness at 10–200 kW. Scale up with modular clusters rather than larger units. |
| Path | Heat-to-output | Net output | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Turbine → generator | 10–15% | 15–22 kWe | Turbine efficiency at this size is the limiting factor. |
| B Turbine → hydraulic | 8–13% | 12–19 kW hydraulic | Extra pump stage. Gearbox if turbine speed is high. |
| C Piston → hydraulic (direct) | 11–15% | 16–22 kW hydraulic | Best for hydraulic-only duty. |
| C′ Batch-heated piston | 3–6% | 4–9 kW hydraulic | Avoid. |
| D CO₂ in ferrofluid | <1% | <1.5 kW | Not viable. |
| S Supermotive free-piston | 11–15% | 16–22 kW (any mix of electric and hydraulic) | Same efficiency as C, plus electricity and self-starting. |
Assumes CO₂ heated to about 220–260 °C by the flue-gas/thermal-oil loop, cooling water at about 10–15 °C, recuperation, and net of CO₂ pump work. Wood boiler efficiency (typically 65–80%) is not included. Multiply by it for fuel-to-output figures.
| CONTACT Email: greg@infinityturbine.com | AMP |